Many of the assigned articles point out that bias is inherent
and impossible to completely erase. It is refreshing to hear this standpoint as
I have only taken one class previously that has addressed bias in this way. In
this class on how sex and gender are reflected in the brain, we discussed the
myth of objectivity: the idea that it is impossible to look from a disembodied view
at natural phenomena and discern some kind of absolute truth. The professor of
this class pointed out that our cultural ideas of a “neutral,” objective standpoint
effectively has meant through the eyes of white males. This fact is reflected
in several trends throughout scientific research, for example, the assumption
that results gained using male organisms would be true for females as well.
Recently, as this
article describes, policies have been implemented by the NIH to increase experimentation
on both sexes through realizations that including both is critical for the validity
of scientific results. This is an example of basic, pervading bias that
counters the idea of pure objectivity. This idea was also described in the
article by Jared Horvath. I appreciate the way Jared Horvath frames his
discussion of this topic in his article, because it does not privilege complete
truth and objectivity over other kinds of knowledge-seeking and discovery. His
debunking of the idea that famous scientists had bullet-proof experiments and
his assertion that every partially-invalid study contains pieces of information
that are useful and valid for the progression of scientific understanding supports
this point. I like this perspective because I feel like, while increasing the
level of accuracy and validity in science is crucial, pure objectivity is not a
possible or desirable goal. Humanity would be better served through an
acknowledgement of inherent flaws and bias and a goal of identifying the helpful
and misleading aspects of a study through an ongoing process (as described in this article).
Showing posts with label #implicitbias. Show all posts
Showing posts with label #implicitbias. Show all posts
Thursday, January 18, 2018
Monday, January 16, 2017
Skepticism bias may be a thing--and yes we should be afraid
Scientific bias or the “systematic
error introduced into sampling or testing by selecting or encouraging one
outcome or answer over others” continues to be a huge issue in modern
scientific research (Merriam-Webster's collegiate dictionary, n.d.). As Bethany Brookshire wrote in her recent op-ed piece “after
all, science is an endeavor performed by scientists — people who come with
their own beliefs and biases that influence how they see the world.” To support
this, Brookshire points to a recent study published in 2012 examining gender
bias in the hiring process (Moss-Racusin et al. 2012). What is interesting about this
study though is not necessarily the results but rather the conflicting response
to the study between surveyed men and women. Men, it turns out, consistently ranked the
study less favorably than women and, Brookshire writes, also tended to argue with
the results and study design more than their female counterparts.
This
heightened sense of skepticism that men tended to place on the results of the
study might describe a different path for bias to emerge: bias based on the skepticism we show to results. Marshall Shepherd, who highlights this possible phenomenon in his recent piece, states “the irony is [that] many skeptics will criticize the peer
review literature until they find a paper that supports their perspective.”
We,
as scientist, are taught to have a healthy level of skepticism when approaching
scientific results (especially as a recent Nature survey showed that a large percentage of
labs fail to reproduce published results, drawing into question to accuracy of
many positive findings), but one has to wonder: at what point does our
skepticism hinder our ability to form unbiased critiques? Whether that skepticism
comes from our own implicit biases or our subconscious desire for our
hypotheses to be supported, the scientific community must question how strongly we critique unexpected/unfavorable results when those results challenge our own research/beliefs.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)