Showing posts with label #pubpeer. Show all posts
Showing posts with label #pubpeer. Show all posts

Thursday, January 18, 2018

Objectivity is fake


Many of the assigned articles point out that bias is inherent and impossible to completely erase. It is refreshing to hear this standpoint as I have only taken one class previously that has addressed bias in this way. In this class on how sex and gender are reflected in the brain, we discussed the myth of objectivity: the idea that it is impossible to look from a disembodied view at natural phenomena and discern some kind of absolute truth. The professor of this class pointed out that our cultural ideas of a “neutral,” objective standpoint effectively has meant through the eyes of white males. This fact is reflected in several trends throughout scientific research, for example, the assumption that results gained using male organisms would be true for females as well. Recently, as this article describes, policies have been implemented by the NIH to increase experimentation on both sexes through realizations that including both is critical for the validity of scientific results. This is an example of basic, pervading bias that counters the idea of pure objectivity. This idea was also described in the article by Jared Horvath. I appreciate the way Jared Horvath frames his discussion of this topic in his article, because it does not privilege complete truth and objectivity over other kinds of knowledge-seeking and discovery. His debunking of the idea that famous scientists had bullet-proof experiments and his assertion that every partially-invalid study contains pieces of information that are useful and valid for the progression of scientific understanding supports this point. I like this perspective because I feel like, while increasing the level of accuracy and validity in science is crucial, pure objectivity is not a possible or desirable goal. Humanity would be better served through an acknowledgement of inherent flaws and bias and a goal of identifying the helpful and misleading aspects of a study through an ongoing process (as described in this article).

Monday, January 16, 2017

Finding the Beauty in Negative Results

It has long been known that trying to publish a paper merely to present negative results will not land you in a top-ranked scientific journal, and likely not in any at all. This problem alone can very much be seen as one of the bottlenecks of research in the scientific community.

Imagine for a moment you’re a scientist trying to discover the mechanism behind cancer proliferation. You search the wondrous world of PubMed, absorbing the works of brilliant scientists, and getting an understanding as to the current state of cancer research. What you find are papers on what appears to ‘work’; advances in the field. What you don’t find are all the experiments and hypothesizes that didn’t work. Okay, now what? Well, that may not be so bad, right? You can focus on an aspect/gene of interest that has appeared to show exciting and promising results. But what if your focus was on STAP stem cells?

In 2014, a group of prominent scientists had a famous paper published in Nature describing the successful creation of STAP (Stimulus-Triggered Acquisition of Pluripotency) cells, which was thought to be one of the biggest break-throughs in stem cell research at the time. Although, luckily for the scientific community, a peer-review website called PubPeer was also established. On this website, anonymous members of the scientific community posted a multitude of accusations into the legitimacy of the paper and its results. Fellow scientists even repeated the same experiments with vastly different results than the STAP cell paper claimed, thus further proving the paper was a fraud. (It was eventually retracted).

My point? If there wasn’t an established website, such as PubPeer, the fallacies in this paper likely would have taken much longer to be uncovered. This could have led to fellow scientists taking the paper as face value and dedicating countless hours and expense to fall into this ‘rabbit hole’. Publishing negative results could only help the scientific community further have a system of checks and balances, to continue to push science forward. It should be more widely accepted by all tiers of scientific publishing as negative data can still be good data.