Environmentalists, social advocates, and apocalypse-aficionados all enjoy scaring the masses with the idea of the exponential growth of the human population. At first glance, the dire warnings of overpopulation seem completely supported, given the explosion from 2.5 billion people in 1950 to more than 7 billion people today. But is an exponential model, always increasing at an increasing rate (general form: dN/dt = rN), really representative of how we will expand? Intuition says no. There has to be a cap in our growth, right? We cannot keep growing forever. Scientists have been confident of self-limiting growth for centuries. I, for one, like the idea of self-limiting growth, seeing as how the African driver ant queen lays between 3-4 million eggs every month. But here’s the thing: those old-timey predictions of the stabilization of human population failed. A long time ago. In fact, about 5 billion of us should not be here right now, if older predictions were correct. Yet here we are, with roughly 6% of all humans ever born alive right now.
It sure looks exponential, doesn’t it?
But a sharp curve does not mean the math fits.
A wonderful illustration of this is available from Math
Bench. This
tool allows you to find the best fit growth rate over distinct periods: early
(up to 0 CE), mid (0 CE – 1950 CE), and modern (1950-present).
No
exponential model fits that variation! Technology,
it seems, is ruining math. Advances in
food production and medicine (among other things) have allowed for steeper
exponential growth in the modern era.
Ok, you
might be saying, so an exponential function might be able to fit if we just
look at the post-Industrial Revolution age.
That should be all that matters, since we can’t really say that human
civilization is anything like it was in the Bronze Age, right? If you think so, you should be investing
heavily in the Mars colony, because the carrying capacity of Earth will smack
us in the face if we’re not careful. The
most cheerful estimates cap us off at 40 billion, and that is with every human
being surviving with subsistence living (not to mention a civilization of
vegetarians). Good luck with that one,
America. If everyone on Earth lived like
us, we’d have to get by with only 2 billion of our closest friends.
Enter the logistic model, or dN/dt=rN(1-N/K),
where K is carrying capacity. With such divergent beliefs of the true carrying
capacity of Earth (2 – 40 billion), any attempt at a logistic model starts off
handicapped. Couple that with the fact
that all logistic models have an inflection point somewhere (the point at which
growth starts increasing at a decreasing rate), and the problems with fitting a
logistic model multiply. If we look only
at the very recent past, we can squint and see that the inflection point has
been passed (which is by definition at a population of K/2).
If we zoom out, that inflection point
is hard to see:
The best-fit model seems to depend on
our time frame. All because technology
screwed up the statistics.
What does that mean for us? Without technological innovation, carrying
capacity would likely be around 2 billion.
Remember that Mars mission you should be supporting? If we go beyond Earth’s resources, carrying
capacity could become irrelevant (at least in the short term). New worlds, or
even just an influx of new resources (think about Ceres, possibly holding
more freshwater than
all of Earth) changes the game, and perhaps the
model. Without scarcity, there need not
be an inflection point. The more
frightened we become of the impending apocalypse, the more innovative we will
be. In the contest between exponential
and logistic functions to explain human population growth, every new extra-planetary
mission is a point for the exponential model.


